Inkable Docs vs. Blackboard Ally: Detailed Comparison
Blackboard Ally, now called Anthology Ally, is the accessibility tool many universities already pay for. It sits inside the LMS, gives every course file an accessibility score, and produces alternative formats for students. With the ADA Title II deadline approaching, many accessibility teams are asking a harder question: are our course files getting fixed, or only scored?
This comparison looks at what Ally does once it has found a problem, and how that differs from Inkable Docs.
How we wrote this comparison
Every statement about Ally comes from Anthology's own documentation, its 2026 release notes, its public AWS Marketplace listing, or public board records, checked on November 16, 2026. Where Anthology does not describe a capability, we say so rather than assume it is missing.
- What happens after a problem is found
- How deep the checks go
- Where each tool works
- What each tool costs, and what Ally does better
1. Ally scores Word and PowerPoint files but leaves the fixing to instructors
Word documents and PowerPoint decks make up a large share of most courses. When Ally scores one of these files low, its Instructor Feedback panel explains the issue and lists steps to fix it. Then the work moves to the instructor.
The instructor has to download the file, open it in Microsoft Word, PowerPoint, or Google Docs, find each issue Ally described, and work out how to fix it in that application. Then they upload the file to the course again so Ally can re-score it. The tool that found the problem, and knows exactly where it is, does nothing to fix it. An instructor who is not an accessibility specialist is left in a different application, trying to match a list of instructions to their own document.
With Inkable Docs: Inkable Docs checks the Word or PowerPoint file in the LMS, applies fixes for supported issues, and replaces the file in the course. It keeps the original, so an Undo restores it. The instructor never has to leave the LMS or work out a fix from written instructions.
2. Ally's in-place fixes are limited to PDF properties and tags
Ally does make some changes itself: PDF Quick Fixes. These add a missing title or language, run OCR on scanned pages, generate tags (added in July 2026 and off by default), and, since October 2026, add alt text to images in a PDF. Ally then uploads the new PDF over the original.
The limit is the PDF itself. A PDF is a finished output, not a file authors edit. Quick Fixes can change a PDF's properties and tags, but not the content underneath. A heading at the wrong level, a table without real header cells, a confusing reading order, or low-contrast text still has to be fixed in the Word or Google Docs source and exported again. When the instructor next updates the source and exports a new PDF, every Quick Fix applied to the old PDF is lost.
With Inkable Docs: Inkable Docs produces a detailed PDF/UA and Matterhorn Protocol report for course PDFs, and puts the fix where it lasts: in the Google Docs, Word, or PowerPoint source, which then exports an accessible PDF.
3. Rule-based checks miss problems of meaning
Ally checks whether a document has headings, image descriptions, tags, a title, a language, and enough contrast. These are important rules, and they are the right place to start. But a document can pass all of them and still be hard to use with a screen reader.
Some common problems no rule-based check can catch:
- A heading at a valid level that is wrong for its place in the document, such as a subsection marked as Heading 1.
- A list typed with dashes or numbers instead of a real list, so assistive technology cannot announce it as one.
- A title or alt text that is present but says nothing useful.
- Instructions that rely on color alone, such as "answer the questions in red".
- Equations with no text description.
Anthology's documentation describes no Ally check that evaluates whether structure matches meaning.
With Inkable Docs: Inkable Docs reads the content as well as the formatting. It recommends heading levels based on the document's outline, converts typed lists into real lists, flags meaning conveyed only by color, and detects and describes equations.
4. A 100% Ally score does not mean a file is accessible
Ally gives every file a percentage score, and Anthology describes a Perfect score as "no accessibility issues identified". That means no issues identified by Ally's rules. The problems in section 3 can sit in a file with a perfect score.
Scores roll up into a course report and an institutional report, which makes them useful for tracking progress. The risk is that a course dashboard full of high scores is read as proof of compliance, and the human review it still needs never happens.
The same is true of Inkable Docs. No automated tool can replace human judgment. Our capability boundaries page sets out what Inkable Docs automates, what it suggests for an author to approve, and what still needs a person. The difference is how much of the remaining work the tool takes on.
5. Alt text one image at a time
Ally's AI Alt Text Assistant suggests a description for an image. Administrators have to turn it on, and each suggestion needs instructor approval. That review step is right; alt text should be checked by someone who knows the course. But it means descriptions are added image by image.
Inkable Docs generates descriptions for every image in a document at once, for the author to review and edit, and also flags existing alt text that is too vague to help.
6. Ally works in the LMS. Inkable Docs works where documents are written
Ally only sees a file after it has been uploaded to the LMS, so every problem it finds is a problem students may already have hit. Inkable Docs runs the same checks in several places:
- Google Docs and Google Slides, through an add-on that fixes the document as it is written.
- Every major LMS, including Blackboard, Canvas, D2L Brightspace, Moodle, and Schoology, through integrations that check and fix course files, plus Google Classroom.
- Microsoft Word and PowerPoint files, whether they sit in a course, are uploaded directly, or are opened through the ChatGPT and Claude connectors.
Checking a syllabus while it is still being written means the course gets an accessible file from the start, with no score to chase later.
7. Ally is expensive
Ally is licensed for a whole institution and priced by enrolment. Anthology does not publish a price list on its website, but its AWS Marketplace listing for Blackboard Ally shows 12-month contract prices by FTE band:
| Institution size | Listed price range |
|---|---|
| 0–2K FTE | $15,000–$150,000 |
| 8–15K FTE | $59,000–$590,000 |
| 25–50K FTE | $110,000–$1,100,000 |
Those figures exclude implementation, and institutions can negotiate private offers, so actual quotes vary. Public board records show real contracts: City Colleges of Chicago approved up to $73,542 for 2024 alone, and Sauk Valley Community College approved $88,553 over five years for Ally and Ally for Websites. Ally also has the highest list prices of any tool we compared, for a tool that leaves most of the fixing to faculty. Inkable Docs publishes its add-on plans and offers flat institution-wide pricing for LMS integrations.
What Ally does well
A fair comparison should also cover Ally's strengths:
- Alternative formats. Ally lets students download course files in other formats: OCR version of scanned documents, Tagged PDF, HTML, Audio, ePub, Electronic braille, BeeLine Reader, Immersive Reader, Enhanced Reader, Translated version (off by default). Inkable Docs makes these redundant: it fixes the original file, so every student gets the accessible version by default.
- Track record. Ally has been deployed at many institutions for years and has a published Accessibility Conformance Report.
Summary comparison
| Capability | Inkable Docs | Ally |
|---|---|---|
| Where it works | Google Docs and Slides, Microsoft Word and PowerPoint files, Google Classroom, and every major LMS: Blackboard, Canvas, D2L Brightspace, Moodle, and Schoology | Inside the LMS only: Blackboard Learn, Canvas, D2L Brightspace, Moodle, and Schoology |
| Word and PowerPoint files | Fixes the file and replaces it in the course, with an Undo that restores the original | Instructions only. The instructor opens the file in Office or Google Docs, works out the fix, and uploads it again |
| PDF files | Detailed PDF/UA and Matterhorn report. Fixes are made in the source document, then a new PDF is exported | Quick Fixes for title, language, OCR, auto-tagging, and image alt text. Headings, tables, reading order, and contrast still need the source file |
| LMS pages (HTML) | Checks and fixes static course pages in the LMS | Checks LMS editor content and offers fixes for some issues in the course report |
| Checks based on meaning | Judges whether heading levels, lists, and titles match what the content says, and flags meaning conveyed only by color | Rule-based checks. Ally's documentation describes no check of whether structure matches meaning |
| Image alt text | Generates descriptions in bulk for the author to review, and reviews the quality of existing alt text | AI Alt Text Assistant suggests one description at a time. It is off by default and each description needs instructor approval |
| Equations | Detects equations and writes accessible descriptions | Not described in Ally's documentation |
| Alternative formats for students | Redundant: Inkable Docs fixes the original file, so every student gets the accessible version by default | Audio, ePub, electronic braille, HTML, BeeLine, Enhanced Reader, and more |
| Reporting | Course and module reports, institution-wide admin summaries, and daily or weekly instructor summary emails | Course report, institutional report, and usage report |
| Pricing | Published plans for the add-on, and flat institution-wide pricing for LMS integrations | Annual institutional licence priced by FTE band. The public AWS listing starts at $15,000–$150,000 a year for under 2,000 FTE, before implementation |
Sources
- Anthology: Instructor FAQs for Ally
- Anthology: Ally for LMS 2026 release notes
- Blackboard Ally on AWS Marketplace (12-month contract pricing)
- Anthology Ally for LMS Accessibility Conformance Report (2025)
- Sauk Valley Community College board approval for Blackboard Ally (2022)
- City Colleges of Chicago board approval for Blackboard Ally (2024 term)
The verdict
Ally is good at telling an institution where its course files stand and at giving students alternative formats. It is much less helpful once a problem is found: Word and PowerPoint fixes fall to instructors outside the LMS, and PDF fixes stop at properties and tags. If your goal is accessible course files, not just scores, Inkable Docs does more of the fixing, wherever the document is written.